Hello Rachel,
sorry for answering so late. I am just back from visiting some of the
places involved.
On my "Lolita USA" webpages I placed 'Elphinstone' not in Utah but in
Wyoming, though all information given seems to point to Utah (there is more of
it than for any other place in the novel). But there simply is no town in Utah
that meets the most specific of these criteria, that is the topography, the
altitude and the distance to a city with a good bookstore. So I hesitatingly
ended up with Evanston, Wyoming--which is only three miles across the
Wyoming/Utah state line, has an LDS "temple" and is fully oriented towards Salt
Lake City. So it's almost Utah. I did not equate Evanston with 'Elphinstone'
because no imaginary place should be equated with a real one but argued that in
many respects 'Elphinstone' at that time must have been like
Evanston. Also, there is the evocative sound. There simply is no clue at
all that would point to Idaho. 'Utana' obviously is a composite of Utah and
Montana. My suggestion is that 'Duk Duk Ranch' (where Quilty took Lolita on the
Fourth of July, 1949) is a private joke of Nabokov's, referring to the little
old Duck Ranch north of West Yellowstone, Montana where he had spent a happy
summer in 1951 and which in its quiet solitude is just about the opposite of
Quilty's obscene hide-out. So Humberts synthetic western state of 'Utana'
embraces both Utah and Montana.
As for Idaho, that comes in only in Nabokov's screenplay. It has an
altogether different geography from the novel, explicitly
placing 'Beardsley' in Idaho and 'Elphinstone' in Arizona (see e.g. pp.117
and 168), fusing 'Wace' and 'Elphinstone' and cutting short both of
Humbert's and Lolita's journeys across the USA. That's why in Kubrick's film
both Humbert's and Quilty's license plates could well have been Idaho
ones.
I hope this residual Idaho cue will be enough to advance your
project.
Dieter E. Zimmer, Berlin, Germany
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, August 24, 2007 4:36 AM
Subject: [NABOKV-L] QUERY: Elphinstone, Idaho?
------------------
I have a question regarding the location of
Elphinstone in 'Lolita'.
Dieter E. Zimmer, in his "Lolita USA" website very
convincingly places
Elphinstone in Utah. But Idaho seems a likely candidate
as well. Idaho's
nickname is "The Gem State" which fits Humbert's claim that
Elphinstone is
in "a gem of a western state." Also in the 'Lolita'
screenplay Quilty's
car has plates from Idaho. Placing Elphinstone in Idaho
would advance a
project that I am currently working on which makes me
hesitant to follow
this lead without thoroughly exhausting all
possibilities.
Any assistance or suggestions would be greatly
appreciated.
thank you,
Rachel Ronning
Search the Nabokv-L archive with
Google
Contact the
Editors
All private editorial communications, without exception, are
read by both co-editors.
Visit Zembla
View Nabokv-L Policies