A few weeks ago in writing about a recorded recital by pianist
Bennett Lerner of music by his friends I mentioned that hearing some pieces by
the American composer Christopher Berg was for me one of the collection's
special pleasures. One of the selections Lerner played, Restoration, a ``song
transcription'' of a poem by Vladimir Nabokov, became particularly interesting
with further listenings.
The piece was a purely instrumental realisation
of the Nabokov poem, with the melodic line following the rhythm and emotional
inflection of the text. In an email correspondence with Lerner I mentioned that
although I liked the piece very much, I couldn't discern the flow of the words
with any clarity in the music. He sent me a copy of the score, in which the
words are printed above the melodic line, to be heard in the performer's mind
but not sung.
After following it a few times, I was no longer able to
listen to the music without mentally hearing the words, and Berg's skill in
setting poetic texts, even when they were silent in performance, seemed
especially impressive.
Here is a CD programme made up completely of vocal
works by Christopher Berg. In the notes to the disc the annotator writes that
Berg is first and foremost a composer of songs. A short introduction in the same
booklet written by the composer himself concerning the song sequence, Hommage a
Francis Poulenc, states that, ``echos of Poulenc run rampant through my music,
for which I make no apologies. Imitation is, after all, the sincerest form of
flattery.''
They can certainly be heard in some of these songs, which
never sound like outright Poulenc imitations but often glide along on the kind
of genial, free-flowing, often slightly wistful melodies that the older composer
seemed to be able to spin out so effortlessly.
You'll notice this right
at the beginning of the opening work on the programme, Les loisirs de la poste
(``Postal Pastimes''), a series of very brief settings, none even a minute long,
of four-line poems by Mallarme sent as postcard texts to famous artists,
writers, and composers. ``Whistler'', the first played here, has an especially
strong Poulenc accent.
But while listening to the the most imposing work
on the programme, the cantata, Portrait en miniature de Madame de Sevigne, I
forgot all about Poulenc. It sets six magnificently characterful texts drawn
from letters written by Madame de Sevigne between 1668 and 1694.
In her
uniquely eloquent way, the writer reflects on subjects ranging from
superstitious reactions to the comet of 1681 to a gloomy mood brought on by
rainy weather to the magnificent food she is enjoying in the countryside to the
inevitability and unfairness of death.
In a note concerning this
remarkable piece, Berg writes that while he was composing it, he witnessed the
September 11 attack on the World Trade Center in New York City from less than a
mile away.
He doesn't tell in which order the pieces were written, but
the experience certainly must have influenced his decision to end the cantata
with a beautifully somber setting of a passage (from comparatively early in her
life) in which Mme de Sevigne writes: ``I find myself in the midst of an
undertaking that overwhelms me: I was launched on life without my consent; I
have to leave it and that does me in. And just how will I leave it? Am I worthy
of heaven? Or only fit for hell? What an alternative! What a predicament! I am
engulfed by these thoughts, and I find death so terrible that I late life more
for leading me there than for the thorns one encounters along the
way...''
The music here usually catches the character of the text
perfectly, as in the passage where Mme de Sevigne mocks the shocked gossip
unleashed by a certain marriage. Berg scores it for the entire trio of singers,
whose vocal lines chatter and pile on top of each other as they break the juicy
news. There are other times, though, when I thought that the music tended to
gild the lily.
Writing of the tendency people have to find personal
portents in celestial phenomena, Mme de Sevigne writes, ``human pride does
indeed honour itself in believing that there are great doing among the stars
when one has to die.'' Berg gives this a rather grandiose setting, placing
stress on the human pride. But can't it be heard as a tart and ironic commentary
that would have come across more pungently with an understated musical
setting?
The lighter works based on Robert Desnos's little surrealistic
poems for children (written, however, in the concentration camp where he died),
and of Eric Satie's sardonic reflections on the comparative intelligence of
animals and humans are fun.
But for me the finest music on this programme
is the concluding setting of Desnos's La moisson (``Harvest''), another
meditation on the incomprehensibility of death, both personal and cultural, that
the poet was experiencing and witnessing during his last days in
Terezin.
It is beautifully and very movingly sung here by tenor Scott
Murphree. If only all of the singing on this disc were on that level! No
complaints about baritone Richard Lalli, whose interpretation of one of the Mme
de Sevigne settings is one of the disc's highlights. But soprano Tobe
Malawista's voice often coarsens and wobbles to the point where it compromises
the effect of the music.
It seems ungrateful to point this out because
her role in the creation of the programme was a central one. It was she who
chose the passages from Mme de Sevigne's huge correspondence that Berg set, and
who recommended Desnos's children's poem collection, Chantefleurs et
Chantefables to the composer as possible material for musical treatment
(Lutoslawski set a different selection of poems from it for soprano and
orchestra).
Still, Un Americain a Paris will be a happy discovery for any
listener with a strong enough interest in modern vocal music to have read this
far into this review. It can be purchased online from amazon.com and other
internet-based sources.