Subject
Ada-1
From
Date
Body
an appropriate post re Ada's character
----- Original Message -----
From: Carolyn Kunin
To: Vladimir Nabokov Forum
Sent: Sunday, August 17, 2003 4:11 PM
Subject: an appropriate post re Ada's character
To the List,
Well, here it is (the first "appropriate" post):
Don Barton Johnson asked on 13 August [1998,sub]
"Does it bother anyone else that Ada,
so carefree with her favors, chooses (after her first Swiss reunion
with Van) to return to Arizona with her ailing Andrey until his death 17
YEARS later? This strikes me as inconsistent with her character as
displayed everywhere else in the novel."
-------------------------------
BRIAN BOYD <b.boyd@auckland.ac.nz> responds:
There are several kinds of answer:
1. Nabokov of course needs the long separation of Van and Ada for the
rhythm of apparently collapsing time central to the structure of the
novel, and it must be conceded that that is a stronger motive than Ada's
compassion for Andrey. Still, it seems unlikely that with his usual care
in construction Nabokov would not have seen the need to motivate such a
key part of the novel's shape.
2. In fact Ada is consistently shown as having a tender-heartedness as
well as her hard dismissiveness and arrogance. Remember that she responds
to droopy Philip Rack and responds again to far-from-droopy Percy de Prey,
because he faces the danger of war (and indeed dies soon after she sees
him off).
3. Remember also that the description of Andrey that we encounter, like
the account of the feelings Ada has for him, come entirely from Van, not
known for his objectivity or tolerant forbearance in such matters. He sees
Ada's decision only as an incomprehensible waste of (his) time; he never
seems to want to know how Ada sees it. In fact despite their uncanny
relatedness, in various senses, and the intensity and duration of their
passion, there are curious gaps in Van's and Ada's knowledge of each
other.
Brian Boyd
Some questions for discussion:
1) Why 17 years (and not 15 or 20)?
2) Where is the evidence that Ada is soft-hearted ? She is sexually responsive -- not exactly the same thing.
3) Perhaps Ada was in prison? (She is guilty of several crimes, that hard-hearted Ada, vamp of the savannah).
3a) Is it just coincidence that Ada's lovers with one exception are "dead, all dead"?
4) Does Dorothy play any role in this 17 year gap?
----- Original Message -----
From: Carolyn Kunin
To: Vladimir Nabokov Forum
Sent: Sunday, August 17, 2003 4:11 PM
Subject: an appropriate post re Ada's character
To the List,
Well, here it is (the first "appropriate" post):
Don Barton Johnson asked on 13 August [1998,sub]
"Does it bother anyone else that Ada,
so carefree with her favors, chooses (after her first Swiss reunion
with Van) to return to Arizona with her ailing Andrey until his death 17
YEARS later? This strikes me as inconsistent with her character as
displayed everywhere else in the novel."
-------------------------------
BRIAN BOYD <b.boyd@auckland.ac.nz> responds:
There are several kinds of answer:
1. Nabokov of course needs the long separation of Van and Ada for the
rhythm of apparently collapsing time central to the structure of the
novel, and it must be conceded that that is a stronger motive than Ada's
compassion for Andrey. Still, it seems unlikely that with his usual care
in construction Nabokov would not have seen the need to motivate such a
key part of the novel's shape.
2. In fact Ada is consistently shown as having a tender-heartedness as
well as her hard dismissiveness and arrogance. Remember that she responds
to droopy Philip Rack and responds again to far-from-droopy Percy de Prey,
because he faces the danger of war (and indeed dies soon after she sees
him off).
3. Remember also that the description of Andrey that we encounter, like
the account of the feelings Ada has for him, come entirely from Van, not
known for his objectivity or tolerant forbearance in such matters. He sees
Ada's decision only as an incomprehensible waste of (his) time; he never
seems to want to know how Ada sees it. In fact despite their uncanny
relatedness, in various senses, and the intensity and duration of their
passion, there are curious gaps in Van's and Ada's knowledge of each
other.
Brian Boyd
Some questions for discussion:
1) Why 17 years (and not 15 or 20)?
2) Where is the evidence that Ada is soft-hearted ? She is sexually responsive -- not exactly the same thing.
3) Perhaps Ada was in prison? (She is guilty of several crimes, that hard-hearted Ada, vamp of the savannah).
3a) Is it just coincidence that Ada's lovers with one exception are "dead, all dead"?
4) Does Dorothy play any role in this 17 year gap?